The Castle Doctrine Forums

Discuss the massively-multiplayer home defense game.

You are not logged in.

#226 Re: Main Forum » Tripped switch states don't persist after vault reach? » 2013-07-10 07:47:25

Yep. You can build a 'one-time' button by making it inaccessible to the robber, who then has to use an animal to press it. Once the button has been pressed the animal falls into a pit/fries on grid and the switch remains unaccessible to the next robber (unless they bring enough tools to get to it).

#227 Re: Main Forum » Minimum Price to defend the wife from $2000 in tools? » 2013-07-09 14:32:32

And that cost $11k!

jasonrohrer wrote:

It seems like changing animal behavior so that animals avoid standing next to dead animals (like, they smell the death from one square away), but that pit bulls still attack you if you're standing next to a dead animal (their desire to attack overrides their aversion to the death-smell) would change this.

Thus, you could stand behind a dead pit bull and still move around safely.  But the square just beyond the dead pit bull (the one just between you and the next living pit bull) would be a deadly square for you.

This sounds great!

#228 Re: Main Forum » Minimum Price to defend the wife from $2000 in tools? » 2013-07-09 09:39:15

If you reintroduced a tool limit people would just build combo locks again.

I think the heart of this issue is that even with the new animal movement rules and the changes to drugged meat, you still only need to shoot one dog to crowbar the rest. So for the starting money you can likely kill 11 dogs. More than can be bought with starting money, and that's before you even buy any walls!

Since dogs are are the only method of protecting the family, you can assume that a gun and 10 crowbars will get you to the family in any fairly new house. There's no real strategy required — just backtrack and club away.

Sure, you could build a fancy contraption to release a dog behind the robber, preventing him from returning to the shot dog, but that would take up as much space/cost as much as 10 dogs. Its nice, but there's no economic benefit.

The mid-late stages of the game seem quite well balanced at the moment, but the beginning is heavily biased towards the robber. Robbing is a fun way to play the game, but the fallout of this bias is that content is being solved/broken faster than it is being created.

I don't know if making dogs cheaper is a good idea. That fix seems too easy, and prone to dog spamming. What would be great is a nerfing of the gun/crowbar combo (like the oft suggested "pile 'o dogs"), or some other method of protecting the family aside from pitbulls.

#229 Re: Main Forum » Minimum Price to defend the wife from $2000 in tools? » 2013-07-09 08:18:23

This problem is magnified when the player base is small. When there's a lot of folks playing fresh houses get a slightly easier ride.

#230 Re: Main Forum » Minimum Price to defend the wife from $2000 in tools? » 2013-07-09 06:52:07

Yep. $2000 worth of tools still beats $2000 worth of house hands down. And the robber's 2k is infinitely refillable as long as you can get home to the sweet embrace of your noose.

#231 Re: Main Forum » money money money » 2013-07-08 12:22:38

Ahem. Well. This is awkward.

I'll hold off on posting the house as I never quite finished it anyway and I'd like to recreate it. I had built myself into a corner somewhat, and was struggling to convert some of the pre v12 logic over to the new system.

#232 Re: Main Forum » Suicide vandalism exploit? » 2013-07-08 09:13:07

jasonrohrer wrote:

--A vault with $0 in it changes to a different sprite (empty vault sprite) and is NOT reachable to end a robbery (cannot even be stepped on).  Thus, leaving is the only way to end a robbery if the vault is empty (though wife might still have money to be taken).  So, reaching an empty vault with NOT save house damage.

Hurrah! I was hoping for something like this.

#233 Re: Main Forum » Suicide vandalism exploit? » 2013-07-08 06:47:52

dalleck wrote:

If this game has taught me anything...

You forgot Rule #1: Always bring a brick.

#234 Re: Main Forum » money money money » 2013-07-08 06:45:36

I regret to inform you all that Mr Black sadly passed away last night at around 01.15 GMT after an unfortunate incident with a rotary switch.

#235 Re: Main Forum » Sneak peek » 2013-07-06 04:15:40

I enjoyed that image zoom very much.

#236 Re: Main Forum » A proposal about new animal movement? » 2013-07-04 10:45:19

I guess it makes it simpler to create a trap where you need to have a dog behind you to pass.

http://castlefortify.com/c/a85ab71

#237 Re: Main Forum » New wife money behavior » 2013-07-03 13:12:35

I think a 'busted vault' sprite would be useful under these new circumstances.

#238 Re: Main Forum » New tool dumping behavior » 2013-07-03 08:54:38

jasonrohrer wrote:

So, maybe she should hold half of your money after your most recent edit.  Then, after that, she keeps that money, no matter what happens to your vault.  So, after your vault is hit, your house might still show $4000 on the house list, but, reaching the vault again will give the robber $0.

This makes a lot of sense!

#240 Re: Main Forum » New tool dumping behavior » 2013-07-02 15:03:23

Hmm. What if the tools dropped in a house (by leaving/dying/reaching vault) were stored separately to those in the vault? So they only actually come into play when the house owner logs back in, at which point they are added to the vault. On the wage message you could say something like "£XXX worth of tools were discarded in your house".

This would be a thematically consistent fix to the dumping loophole whilst letting the house owner reap the benefits of any discarded tools.

#241 Re: Main Forum » A proposal about new animal movement? » 2013-07-02 11:02:54

As Zed says - if windows are a necessary part of any animatronics then they are too easily foiled. Perhaps the answer is to give animals an 8 (or whatever you think) tile field of awareness. That would keep any hidden mechanics within reasonanble tool reach.

#242 Re: Main Forum » feature request: additional stat tracking and "lifetime kills" » 2013-07-01 12:42:16

Thing is that all-time deaths/visits for a house is data only visible to the owner. It would be nice for that information to be publicly visible. A little testament to longevity!

#243 Re: Main Forum » feature request: additional stat tracking and "lifetime kills" » 2013-07-01 09:44:22

I'd love some lifetime stats for the houses. Might be nice to have a button to toggle between lifetime/live stats.

#245 Re: Main Forum » Can we walk over trapdoors in build mode already? » 2013-07-01 00:21:39

It seems that any trapdoors turned on when your vault is reached will stay on in house edit mode until you begin the self test.

#246 Re: Main Forum » Tapes duration » 2013-06-30 07:16:59

I think an icon to show that tools were carried into the house would be a useful aid when combing through pages of tapes.

#248 Main Forum » Wife & vault in single hit » 2013-06-28 16:43:30

ukuko
Replies: 2

It seems in V10 that if you murder somebody's wife, grab her loot and reach the vault you still only get 50% of the total house value.

I don't think that used to be the case...

#249 Re: Main Forum » Green text on unvisited houses » 2013-06-28 07:56:03

Good points. I rescind my request!

The owner might change something out from underneath you without you realizing it (a good thing in terms of tactical gameplay).

Under what conditions does the visits/deaths counter reset?

It seems to reset whenever something in a house changes, as you'd expect, but there have been times when I've changed something in my house and the counter I see on my tapes hasn't reset. Unless I'm going crazy, which is always possible.

#250 Main Forum » Green text on unvisited houses » 2013-06-28 06:03:00

ukuko
Replies: 3

I love the green text on unwatched tapes in v10. How about green text for unvisited houses?

Guess it would also count them as unvisited if the owner changed something since your last visit.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB 1.5.10